Genocide is not principally a legal concept. It is a word that invokes the paradigm case of the Holocaust. Any “judgment” that strays too far from the Holocaust is an absurdity.
I'm not clear why you say lthe ICJ is about to accuse Israel of genocide When South Africa's next statement is not due until November 2027 and Israel's reply is not due until May 2029. I may be misunderstanding. Can you explain?
I wonder if Rwanda qualifies as a genocide. Or the Holodomor. I think that, as Jews, we can recognize that man's supreme inhumanity to man is not a one-time occurrence, without weakening our cry that the Israeli government is not committing a genocide in Gaza.
Rwanda definitely is. Srebrenica isn't, but must be accepted as a court giving a judgment in a hard case. Gaza is an absurdity as it falls miles outside the paradigm case. Please read the book to understand the argument.
I'm not clear why you say lthe ICJ is about to accuse Israel of genocide When South Africa's next statement is not due until November 2027 and Israel's reply is not due until May 2029. I may be misunderstanding. Can you explain?
Not immediately of course, but this was the first act.
I wonder if Rwanda qualifies as a genocide. Or the Holodomor. I think that, as Jews, we can recognize that man's supreme inhumanity to man is not a one-time occurrence, without weakening our cry that the Israeli government is not committing a genocide in Gaza.
Rwanda definitely is. Srebrenica isn't, but must be accepted as a court giving a judgment in a hard case. Gaza is an absurdity as it falls miles outside the paradigm case. Please read the book to understand the argument.