6 Comments
User's avatar
Noah Otte's avatar

Comments can boost the engagement with a post, so I thought I’d include some of my famous nuance examples. 😉 Read those below 👇

Let’s say I’m living in Australia in the 1800s. I would be a proud Australian settler, start a ranch on the frontier and live there with my family, be happy to see the expansion of free settlements, celebrate the 1851 Gold Rush, welcome the waves of immigration from Britain, Europe, China, and North America, be excited by the rapid growth of cities like Sydney and Melbourne, support the introduction of the secret ballot in 1856, support the introduction of women’s suffrage in Southern Australia in 1894 and Western Australia in 1899, and be glad to hear about the end of the transportation of convicts to the eastern colonies. But at the same time, I would support the Rum and the Eureka Rebellions, oppose violence on the frontier against the Aboriginal people, oppose the systemic dispossession of Aboriginal land, publicly denounce massacres perpetrated by Australian colonists against the Aboriginal people, oppose anti-Chinese immigration laws, and fight against the blackbirding or kidnapping of Pacific Islanders from the South Pacific for use as forced labor.

Let’s say I lived in South Vietnam during its existence from 1955-1975. I would be proud to be South Vietnamese, fly the South Vietnamese flag, celebrate independence from France, be grateful to have the United States as our ally, be glad to live in the capitalist South rather than the Communist North, I would be a staunch anti-Communist, enlist in the ARVN, detest the North Vietnamese and the Viet Cong, admire Ngo Dinh Diem and Ngo Dinh Nhu, welcome the American and Free World Forces who arrived in South Vietnam to fight the Communists, and celebrate North Vietnam recognizing South Vietnam in the 1973 Paris Peace Accords. All that being said, I would lobby for the French to continue to have a military presence in South Vietnam for the protection of my people, seek to build peaceful relations between Catholics and Buddhists, be shocked by the assassinations of Diem and Nhu, would not support any of Diem’s corrupt and incompetent successors, criticize the American government for how they were waging the Vietnam War, call out atrocities by the American military and the ARVN, be appalled by the 1968 My Lai Massacre, have sympathy for North Vietnamese civilians killed as collateral damage in U.S. bombing campaigns, and would help as many of my people to get to safety as I could before fleeing to America with my family with the Fall of Saigon in 1975.

Let’s say I’m living in Kenya in the 1950s. I would be a proud Kenyan, call out British atrocities and injustices, fight racism against my people, protest the expropriation of our land by white settlers, advocate for greater self-autonomy and eventual independence for Kenya, oppose my people being held in detention camps during the Mau Mau Uprising, and denounce the rape of our women by British and allied Kenyan soldiers. But at the same time, I would support Kenya remaining part of the British Empire, be proud to be a citizen of the empire, tout the benefits of the British colonialism, befriend white settlers, advocate for a democratic, capitalist and multicultural Kenya where whites, blacks, mulattos, and Asians would all live together as equals, work to convince British settlers, Greek and Italian immigrants and Boer farmers to stay, protect civilians black and white alike from the Mau Mau, join the Kikuyu Home Guard and fight alongside the British, detest the Mau Mau and be appalled by their crimes, and detest Jomo Kenyatta and consider him a con artist.

Daniel Clarke-Serret's avatar

Always enjoy a bit of Noah nuance.

Noah Otte's avatar

An excellent and shocking article by Jens Heycke about a crucial topic! It is totally unacceptable and appalling that in a free country like Britain, freedom of speech is absolute accept when it comes to Islam. Islam is considered untouchable in Britain and in the entire western world as Jens shows perfectly with several notable cases studies. Speakers’ Corner is a place where ALL speech and viewpoints should be welcome!

This is why I’ve long advocated for Britain to adopt its own first amendment rights guarantee the right to free speech. Criticism of Islam is NOT the problem! The problem is those who are so fanatical they feel the murder anyone for depicting the Prophet Mohammed or saying something negative about Islam. Nor should anyone lose their job or go to jail because they dared to hurt the feelings of conservative or radical Muslims. Islam is like any other religion and should be held to the same standards! No more double standards in how the law is enforced around criticism of religions in Britain or anywhere else in the western world!

It’s sad but not at all surprising, to me that even here in the United States, criticism of Islam is verboten. We have the first amendment, but the authorities decide to selectively enforce the law. That also needs to stop. Islamophobia is disgusting and wrong. We all agree legitimate prejudice and hate crimes against Muslims are despicable and the former should be condemned and the latter prosecuted. But Islam should be open to criticism just as much as Christianity, Judaism, Buddhism, Hinduism, or any other faith is. Criticism of religion should be applied universally! There are legitimate issues with Islam that need to be brought into the light of day!

Noah Otte's avatar

Here are some resources on related to this topics article:

• Islam and Free Speech by Andrew McCarthy

• Lights Out: Islam, Free Speech And The Twilight Of The West by Mark Steyn

• Sharia Versus the U.S. Constitution: Why Americans Must Choose Freedom by A.S. Ibrahim

• A Battle for the Soul of Islam: An American Muslim Patriot's Fight to Save His Faith by A. Zuhdi Jasser

• No Compulsion in Religion ― No Exceptions: Islamic Arguments for Religious Freedom by Mustafa Akyol

• Islam Without Extremes: A Muslim Case for Liberty by Mustafa Akyol

• Murder in Amsterdam: Liberal Europe, Islam, and the Limits of Tolerence by Ian Buruma

• Reflections on the Revolution In Europe: Immigration, Islam and the West by Christopher Caldwell

• Suicidal Empathy: Dying to Be Kind by Gad Saad

• Suicide of a Nation: Immigration, Islam, Identity by Matt Goodwin

• Free Speech Generation: The Civil Libertarians Who Saved the First Amendment and Transformed America by Nico Perrino

• The War On Words: 10 Arguments Against Free Speech—And Why They Fail by Greg Lukianoff & Nadine Strossen

• HATE: Why We Should Resist it With Free Speech, Not Censorship by Nadine Strossen

• The Indispensable Right: Free Speech in an Age of Rage by Jonathan Turley

• Free Expression Under Fire: Defending Free Speech and Free Press Across the Political Spectrum by Stuart N. Brotman

Kip 🇺🇸🇮🇱🟦's avatar

Terrifying. Thanks for your reporting.